The Roots Beneath the Silence

The question that haunted Riverhaven for decades was simple—too simple, perhaps:

Why did the poison strike each guest differently?
Why did some choke, some bleed, some seize, some simply fall?

Doctors blamed poor health. Ministers blamed sin. Plantation owners blamed hysteria.
But none of them understood the truth.

Only one man ever came close.

Three Months After the Deaths

Dr. Elias Marrow arrived from New Orleans, summoned by a committee of wealthy planters desperate to protect their reputations. He was known for two things: his sharp mind and his refusal to bend truth for the comfort of the wealthy.

He walked the abandoned Caldwell dining hall, tapping his cane softly across the floorboards. The long table still bore faint stains—wine, fear, and something else. Something that had seeped too deep to scrub away.

Moses followed quietly behind him.

“You were the last to see the cook?” Dr. Marrow asked.

Moses hesitated. “Yes, sir.”

“You believe she poisoned them.”

Moses did not respond. Instead, he pointed to the table. “You askin’ the wrong question, sir.”

Dr. Marrow arched an eyebrow. “And what is the right one?”

“Why it didn’t kill ‘em the same way.”

The doctor’s eyes sharpened.
“That,” he murmured, “is precisely why I am here.”

The Discovery

Dr. Marrow spent days gathering samples: dried duck glaze, crumbs of sweet potato soufflé, residue from the oyster stew. But what interested him most were the plants Moses brought from the swamp at the edge of Riverhaven—plants Celia had often collected.

“Swear she talked to the woods,” Moses whispered. “Like the ground itself answered her.”

Dr. Marrow examined the leaves, crushed the roots, inhaled the ghost of their scent.
“Fascinating,” he muttered. “These aren’t common herbs. They’re… specific. Purposed.”

“Purposed how?” Moses asked.

“To draw out what lies weakest in a body.”

Moses frowned. “Meanin’?”

Dr. Marrow placed three vials on the table.

“This one attacks the lungs,” he said.
“This one attacks the heart.”
“This one attacks the blood.”

Moses swallowed. “But how she know who’d fall which way?”

“She didn’t,” the doctor said softly. “They told her.”

Moses blinked. “Told her?”

Dr. Marrow nodded toward the old Caldwell diaries he had uncovered—schedules of punishments, overseers’ reports, medical notes about various ailments.

“She observed. She listened. She remembered every cough, every limp, every weakness these people carried yet never hid from those who served their dinners.”

He tapped the vials.

“She didn’t poison twenty people the same way.
She tailored justice.”

Moses let out a long breath—half awe, half sorrow.

“So the questions are answered,” Dr. Marrow said. “The mystery solved.”

But Moses shook his head.

“No, sir. You missin’ the last piece.”

“And what is that?” the doctor asked.

Moses approached the long dining table, placing his calloused hand on the wood.

“Why the poison spared the ones it should’ve spared.”

Dr. Marrow glanced toward the stairway—toward the rooms where the children slept peacefully that terrible night.

He nodded slowly.

“The herbs respond to intention,” he whispered. “Some plants in this world… they listen. They follow the hand that prepares them.”

Moses met his gaze.

“Then Celia didn’t just know plants, sir.”
“She commanded them.”

The Unspoken Truth

Dr. Marrow dismissed the committee, claiming the deaths were from contaminated food.
He burned his notes.
He refused all further inquiries.

Years later, on his deathbed, he confided one final truth to his apprentice:

“There are sciences we measure,” he rasped. “And sciences we fear.
The woman at Riverhaven… she wielded the second.”

His apprentice asked what he meant.

Dr. Marrow smiled faintly, eyes glazing over.

“She served justice,” he murmured. “And the earth itself obeyed her.”

He never spoke again.

And so the mystery faded into legend.
But in the deep, patient soil of Mississippi, the truth remains:

Celia’s justice worked differently for each person…
because the land remembered what they had done.
And because she—more than anyone living—knew how to ask it to speak.